Official "Should I" Thread

Mario YO!

 

After the Rivers stinker against KC (and Stafford on bye), I have to grab a waiver wire QB and keep Rivers on the bench.

Pick 1

Josh Freeman @NO
Alex Smith @WAS
Carson Palmer vs DEN
Tim Tebow @OAK
Kevin Kolb vs STL
Tavaris Jackson @DAL
Curtis Painter @ATL
John Beck vs SF

Or am I stuck with Rivers as my best option?

 

Josh Freeman. He already scorched the Saints once. Though he has been really bad, he's usually a decent play. Coming off a bye week, he could be really good. Let's hope so anyway.

 

Ya, Freeman should be a good option the rest of the way.

Check the Bucs schedule. Quite a few high-scoring teams. They'll have to throw a lot & you always get those extra rushing yards with him.

 

Whos better TE going the rest of the way? Heath Miller or Jermichael Finley?

 

Finley no contest.

 

Tony Romo or Josh Freeman Week 9?

David Nelson or Eric Decker Week 9 in PPR League?

 

I also just got offered Matt Forte & Ryan Mathews for Adrian Peterson & Jackie Battle... Mendenhall is my RB2... I also have Jahvid Best on my roster.

 

Not that great of a thing that Freeman may have to throw a lot. He seems very interception prone lately, and his targets aren't world beaters, at least not yet. Benn and Williams are good but I guess they and Freeman have started to show their green-ness.

 

Should I buy super-mega low on CJ0K for Crabtree? PPR league

 

CJ is practically benched... he's probably going to be sharing touches now with that second stringer... Crabtree is actually pretty valuable in a PPR league, he gets a hell of a lot of looks. Depends if you already have other good WRs and you don't need Crabtree and you are willing to gamble for a potentially good RB.

 

Will Sam Bradford play this weekend? I've got Cam Newton on the bye week and don't have a back up QB. He and Matt Cassell are on the waiver wire and need to pick up one of them.

Also should I drop Jabbar Gaffney for Davone Bess@KC or Mike Williams@NO?

 

I don't even think he's jogging yet last time I checked.

 

I need a bye week replacement, should I go with Jay Cutler or Andy Dalton?

Thanks in advance

 

what do you think about this trade I got offered:

RECEIVE:

TE J. Finley
WR. V. Cruz
RB. R. Helu

GIVE

TE: Witten

my current RBs: McCoy, Starks, Morris, Moreno
my current WRs: Mike Wallace, Reggie Wayne, Deion Branch, Decker, Julio Jones.

Im thinking not, I think my WRs, can produce the same as Cruz, and Helu is not a huge upgrade, and Witten more consistent than Finley

I was thinking to counter with:

RECEIVE

Finley
Turner

GIVE

Witten
Starks
Wayne or Decker.

Thanks in Advance

 

Fitzpatrick vs Jets

or

Ryan vs Indy

 

The Jets have been weak against the run so I can see the Bills running Fred Jackson down their throats, thus limiting Fitz's numbers.


Which defence has a better matchup? Chiefs DST vs Dolphins or Falcons DST @ Colts

 

Easy call, Ryan.

 

Def go with Ryan against the team with a ****ty QB and ****ty RBs.

 

I like your counter given that he seems to overvalue Witten. Worst case, I would do the first deal and cut Morris and Branch (or find a way to trade a WR if you're attached to Branch)