As opposed to the now silly Schaub vs Eli question. Who do you think is better between Eli and Big Ben? Would you base it on who you would rather have on your team? Who you think has a better Hall of Fame case? Who is a better clutch player? Make your wager.
That's only reason I'd take Eli. Ben has been having injury problems as of late (not to mention raping people problems). At some point either the injuries or the law will catch up to him. I think Eli will have a longer career.