Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!
I guess that’s our fundamental disagreement. I think 2024 he will be as good or better than Meyers, he might be now, and we have enough defense to...
Trade him. That’s also Gilbert’s floor I bet and between Chas, Tucker, Yordan, Gilbert and whoever else come us we will be fine. Jake has to be...
You are arguing for a cy young guy as opposed to a TOR guy imo. Anyone pitching 150 ish innings, reasonably ready to go in the playoffs, with a...
LMJ is another example I can think of as a guy that was working on some specific stuff and ended up having better numbers in the bigs than in the...
I’d do that deal because I trust the astros to produce a JP France or better guy every year. Which is really valuable as an organization. Most...
That seems about right to me then. That makes Jake's floor an out standing 4th OF with 4.5 years of club control for cheap- or a starter on a...
I think you are right about France probably being a #4 type starter, but I don't think you can call that a floor. He could be John Halama- a guy...
This is an interesting last paragraph- what do you think Gilbert's floor is? What do you think his ceiling is? I see a floor of Jake Meyers with...
Any idea where Meyers is?
Here’s my argument- I’d trade Presley for Hader (maybe) even though Hader is in a walk year, because I think Hader is better than Presley and...
Pod up for our trade value part 1 column with the 12 Astros with the absolute most trade value. These guys are all really good/really valuable!...
They are in the second pod. Think of it this way - Presley is making 14 million. Who would want him before they would ask for Peña or Gilbert or...
At the beginning of the year I said maybe they should consider it. Springer was better but Chas was a better value and we had left over money to...
Just got done with our trade value (2 part) pod. We were in agreement on the top 11 fitting into 3 tiers but we had many different orders to our...
I said the astros should ask the blue jays about a Chas for Springer deal and I was called the dumbest son of a b**** on the planet here. I was,...
It’s one game. I would trust him implicitly as I think he has the best stuff in the league.
Yeah- scherzer is far from some sort of guaranteed bet in the playoffs. If I was going to rank dudes I trusted in the playoffs it might be...
probably right. But, subtracting out the bullshit balls would give you a bit of a better idea of how bad the actual penalty is that Bregman has...
Yeah- I wasn't counting on sentimentality, just wondering if we would be a team that he gives a thumbs up to. i'd think he would but who knows...
