1. Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

  2. ROCKETS GAMEDAY
    The Rockets continue their home tour of tanking teams with a contest against the 21-56 Utah Jazz. Join Dave & Ben for live postgame.

    LIVE! ClutchFans on YouTube

Opinions on my writing

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout' started by Drexlerfan22, Dec 14, 2002.

  1. Drexlerfan22

    Drexlerfan22 Member

    Joined:
    Apr 6, 2002
    Messages:
    6,366
    Likes Received:
    528
    A while ago I posted a thread asking people to critique part of a story I had written, which is presently 45 pages long. Looking at it again, and from the feedback I got, some of my description, especially environmental description, was a little weak. I've written this short story (below) to practice and flex my descriptive skills, and I want to see what people think. Any feedback, but especially specific criticism, is appreciated. Thanks.


    Untitled
    by Joe Petek

    He sat by himself, watching for anything, waiting for nothing. His mind was set on nothing in particular. Instead it wandered like a restless animal, a dog with its nose pressed against the glass, agitated and ready to run. It pined for attention, the bothersome tasks of the day employing a feeble whine. Yet, his body was tired… not an unpleasant tiredness, but one which can come from a good, long swim, or a hike in a quiet place. It was that kind of tiredness that set you soon to sleep, and did not linger in the morning.
    He sat in the open air, on the ground. His gaze was not fixed, but lazy, unprovoked by any worrisome sight. The school grounds looked much as they always had, and the few who still remained walked with urgency, bending their heads as the rain came down. None of them came near where he sat, his head laid back against the wall, legs drawn up to his chest, arms wrapped around his shins. His eyes fled to the treetops with the slow sureness of an ocean wave, rolling inexplicably up towards the shore of the horizon, until they ran up into the cloudy sky of their own accord. The clouds looked like a quilt wrapped around the sky, protecting him from the bothers of the world. No one could see him, or find him.
    He closed his eyes.
    The sound of the rain drowned out the sounds in his mind, the sounds which are heard in total silence and come only from within, and which make men nervous. The rain kept falling, washing away the place where he sat like wind blowing away sand to reveal a black stone pathway to nowhere. In the blackness time shrank until it was the size of a drop of rain, echoing on the ground over and over again to eternity. The rain seemed to poke gentle fun at time, while the clouds went so far as to cover and hide the clock that all men see. The clouds, the rain… they seemed like old friends, happy to do mischief for the happiness of their companion.
    He was not cold, but pleasantly warm, his cotton sweater holding in the heat. The hood was pulled over his head, making a cushion on the hard wall. It was damp from a mad dash under the open air, when the rain was his oppressor, and the wind his rival. The sweater smelled like only damp cotton can, filling each of his slow, deep breaths with its odor. It reminded him of home, and a fire, and looking out the window at the rain… feeling safe.
    But suddenly he yearned for air. His hands rose slowly in the blackness, timid. They pulled the hood off his head, and he leaned forward, breathing deeply. The air was cold enough that he could feel it enter his lungs like a cold drink of water on a summer day… but it tasted better than water.
    His eyes opened, slow and reluctant as a man emerging from a dark cave into the light, or a sleeper arising in a cold room from under warm covers. The light poured into his eyes like water from a bucket, the color of the world faded like a child’s watercolor to his newly opening eyes… and yet everything was outlined sharply. The world before had been too colorful; the brightness of it had made colors mix and blend like the lights on a Christmas tree seen from a distance. Now all things were clean, clear, and serene. The trees swayed in the breeze, slowly dancing to the music of the wind, while yellow leaves broke away and flew exuberantly through the air like children running with all their strength out into an open field while their mother called to them in vain exasperation.
    The boy stood up with the slowness of one who is very old. Then he stood among the things of the world, the trees, the grass, the buildings, the wind, the rain, the clouds, the sounds of the storm, the smells of a rainy day, and disappeared. He looked into eternity, to where the world ended in a thoughtful silence, then gently smiled. His prayer was finished, and he began walking home.
     
  2. Cohen

    Cohen Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    10,751
    Likes Received:
    6
    I like the mood that you convey, and your relaxed style.

    I assume that you are experimenting with similes, since it is very very full of them (sometimes things are just what they are :) ). You similes are like a waterfall, or the river's current, or... ;) :)

    Also, one thing that seems to stand out: missplacement on 'contrary' type statements (maybe there's a word for it, I don't know). E.g., 'His gaze was not fixed, but lazy...' would make sense if there was some reason why his gaze should be fixed. Same with 'He was not cold, but pleasantly warm,...'. Why should I expect him to be cold? He was sitting in the rain, but I don't really know if he's soaking wet.

    Also, where did the praying come from? I thought his mind was wandering.

    Trivial really. FWIW, I like it.
     
  3. KingCheetah

    KingCheetah Atomic Playboy

    Joined:
    Jun 3, 2002
    Messages:
    60,366
    Likes Received:
    54,948
    I enjoyed the first part of the work you posted, getting all the input is a great way to fine tune.
    Here is my two bits, overuse of the same descriptive word makes your writing seem rushed. How about something like this:
    The pleasant exhaustion of a full day now complete, he would soon be in a deep slumber not to stir until mornings light.

    It also jumps from 1st to 3rd person which can be confusing.
    Keep up the great work, you've got a good mood building :)
     
  4. heypartner

    heypartner Member

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 1999
    Messages:
    64,129
    Likes Received:
    60,196
    DF22,

    this was fun to read. there was a lot I liked. your talent seems as suited to poetry as prose... Your descriptions and similes are nice and easy to read like they were meant to be said. But, you make too many of them.

    read this:

    <i>The trees swayed in the breeze, slowly dancing to the music of the wind, while yellow leaves broke away and flew exuberantly through the air like children running with all their strength out into an open field while their mother called to them in vain exasperation. </i>

    that is nice and poetic, but, in its place right where you are trying to wrap it up, it ends up separating us from the meaning of the prose. It is eye candy.

    And in the end, I don't know what the last (seemingly most important) sentence means...

    "His prayer was finished, and he began walking home."

    What prayer? I really don't know much about the boy versus your nice descriptions of the surroundings and his place in them. I don't know what "sounds in his mind" the rain was drowning out, especially since
    "his mind was set on nothing in particular" at first. I don't know why he is tired.

    At best, all I can gather is that he "then gently smiled" to your description of the world around him and that description was his prayer so he smiled, and he "began walking again."

    You seem more focused on describing the time and place than telling a story of something that we will remember. In other words, your writing here seems to be eye-candy for a reader with little story telling.

    try using you skills on describing the protean difference between people as well as setting, time and place. If you want to describe only setting and a singular feeling, you might be better suited for poetry than prose. In prose, we, as the readers, really have to be attached to a person/thing as much as the setting, especially if you intend to start and end the short story based on a person, like you did.

    Maybe consider writing a short story without a person. Something void of people, yet yearning for them. A place that we remember, or where we want to go. Or a time that we remember.
     
  5. Drexlerfan22

    Drexlerfan22 Member

    Joined:
    Apr 6, 2002
    Messages:
    6,366
    Likes Received:
    528
    Thanks for the feedback. It seems like with all the similes, people are coming out of the story a little bit. Maybe the similes are too much like angry hammers, assaulting the reader like...

    uhhh... yeah ;).

    Seriously, comments have been helpful so far. Thanks.

    Sorry that it has no plot, but I didn't really intend it to... just a writing exercise... an experiment.
     
  6. KingCheetah

    KingCheetah Atomic Playboy

    Joined:
    Jun 3, 2002
    Messages:
    60,366
    Likes Received:
    54,948
    Are you still working on the Sci/Fi project or are you giving it a rest until you develop your writing style to your liking?
     
  7. Drexlerfan22

    Drexlerfan22 Member

    Joined:
    Apr 6, 2002
    Messages:
    6,366
    Likes Received:
    528
    The fact is, I don't think anyone has ever written anything and then looked at it 6 months later and been totally satisfied with it. I haven't touched my sci/fi thing in about a month. I'm going to look at it soon. I might decide to keep writing it, or I may decide to rewrite most of it, or just scrap the whole thing... I'm not sure. But I'm not going to "develop my writing style to my liking" first... I don't think anyone's ever happy with it.
     
  8. Cohen

    Cohen Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    10,751
    Likes Received:
    6
    Reminds me of a book published a few years ago by an Irish writer. Actually, he wasn't a writer, but began a novel 20 or 30 years ago, and just continued to refine it. I guess he never thought that it would not amount to much.

    When a publisher finally saw it, they didn't change a word and it was received with much critical acclaim.
     
  9. heypartner

    heypartner Member

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 1999
    Messages:
    64,129
    Likes Received:
    60,196
    DF22,

    I just want to say that the motivation for my "critique" was based on you asking for it, and me really liking a lot of what I read. I can certainly appreciate your practice of just writing as an exercise.

    I would really like to read a short story of yours that is totally void of people, yet completely about people. That is a tough one, but it is the basis of a lot of poetry, and I think you have the knack.

    get posting your writing!!!
     

Share This Page