Official "Should I" Thread

Agreed. Though its tempting considering how dominant Gronk can be.


Another proposed trade (3 way)

I send out: Steven Jackson and Demaryius Thomas
I receive: Trent Richardson and Wes Welker.

What do you guys think?

 

Vernon Davis is my flex and news says he's a "True Game Time Decision" ... at this point should I just put Fred Jackson or T.Y. Hilton in my flex spot? I reckon, Davis isn't going to be full strength even if he does play.

@ Lil Pun: That's a tough call. Bengals are at home, and I (still) respect Baltimore D. I think I would go Dalton, but I'm not really sure man. Sorry.

 

I'd roll with Dalton at home against the 30th ranked pass defense in the NFL.

 

Yes, it's not worth getting a goose egg at FLEX.

I'd start T.Y., who should get a lot of targets in a pass-happy game in SF this afternoon.

 

Pick 2 for TE and W/R/T Flex:
J. Cook @DAL
M. Bennett @PIT
Gio Bernard vGB

 

Cook and Bernard.

I think CHI will struggle to score in Pittsburgh, so Martellus will come back to earth after a couple of big games in the first 2 weeks.

 

Thanks Wood. I'm gonna take your advice. Good luck to everyone this week.

 

Hilton didn't practice all week and that has me nervous. I have hilton on my team and I am benching him.

Even if Hilton has a great game, there is significant risk involved in playing him. I'm actually considering playing Sidney Rice, over him.

 

Boo...I've got Bennet starting this week (in place of Davis) and Forte too! Here's hoping you're wrong on this one, although I do have a bad feeling on this too. I can't imagine Steelers going 0-3.

 

He practiced with the team on Friday and is currently listed as probable.

 

he was a 'limited participate" and I am not arguing that he will play.

 

Someone is offering me Stevan Ridley for Pierre Garcon.

I already have Doug Martin/Matt Forte/Knowshon Moreno at HB, and I have Welker/Bowe/Torrey Smith at wideout.

I am leaning towards keeping Garcon, but HBs are so valuable. Thoughts?

 

I would keep Jackson and Thomas. I think Richardson's values goes down in Indy because Bradshaw will get a good load of work and Thomas a tier higher than Welker.

 

Ok this guy with a depleted receiving core offered me Aaron Rodgers for Cam Newton and Steve Johnson. And then asked for more when I said yes via text.

How do I talk him back into his original offer?

 

Hmm, I just got offered Josh Gordon and Trent Richardson for Dez Bryant. Leaning heavily no, but I'm not quite sure.

 

Man, I'm talking myself into this deal the more I think about it. I like the upside of Richardson and Gordon, and I've been winning with Bryant producing very little in two games.

 

Gordon's on the verge of getting dealt, which may spike his value even more, especially if it's to a contender in need of a legit threat at WR (9ers, Pats, Hawks). T-Rich will only get better as the season progresses, especially next to a blossoming young QB in Luck.

Bryant's a stud, but he always seems to be hampered by injuries.

I'd hang on to Gordon and T-Rich.

 

Got offered Jimmy Graham for Julio Jones. Should I?

My other receivers are Desean Jackson, Josh Gordon, Eric Decker and Stevie Johnson