[NBA] Official "Should I" Thread

Should i drop Greg Oden given that Tyson Chandler is on free agents list?

 

Depends on your league's setup and whether you have a greater need for a healthy player or one with a large penis.

 

My league does have a penis size cat....hmmm.

 

Dwight Howard is a fantasy power house. I have won my league 3 years in a row drafting him in the first round. Losing FT% means nothing if he wins you blocks, rebounds, and FG% every week.

pretty solid team you have actually, could use some steals though

 

If rebounds count as 2 stats then ya, Howard def holds value.

 

Somebody offered me Ben Gordon and Derric Favors for Brooks? Yay or nay?

 

Nah, Brooks will bring you just about maybe even more than Gordon as far as three pointers and scoring goes. He also has about 5-6 assists per game, that may increase now that Yao's back for at least half the game.

Favors is a bench throw in, especially when Troy Murphy comes back.

 

no, Brooks led the league in 3 pointers made, that is a valuable thing to have on ur team

 

I need some advice. This year my plan was to stock up on a certain position because I wanted to try to win at least in 5 categories each week. I loaded up on several bigs because I wanted to also have trade assets. I have the best big men lineup in my whole league.

I had several offers but I wasn't sure which one to go with. Most of my teams want someone from my bigs. Mainly Blake Griffin, Big Z, and K-Love. I have one guy right now that's trying to send me Wall for one of my bigs. I think Wall will be great but I don't know if he's a guy I really need. He wanted Griffin or Big Z for Wall. The other guy I know really really wants Blake Griffin. We've been talking about doing a Rondo for Griffin trade. He also said he was willing to trade KD to me but I don't know what trade offer I would be willing to give. What do you guys think? I know at it stands right now, I have a chance at winning in points, FG%, blocks, rebounds, and maybe FT%. If I can land Rondo, I think I have a shot at assists as well.

I have enough bigs to make a solid trade but I don't know what for yet...


1. (4) Deron Williams (Uta - PG)
2. (13) Pau Gasol (LAL - PF,C)
3. (20) Brook Lopez (NJ - C)
4. (29) Zach Randolph (Mem - PF,C)
5. (36) Kevin Love (Min - PF,C)
6. (45) Blake Griffin (LAC - PF)
7. (52) Devin Harris (NJ - PG)
8. (61) Jason Richardson (Pho - SG,SF)
9. (68) Gilbert Arenas (Was - PG,SG)
10. (77) Luol Deng (Chi - SF)
11. (84) Anthony Randolph (NY - PF,C)
12. (93) Emeka Okafor (NO - C)
13. (100) Corey Maggette (Mil - SF,PF)
14. (109) J.J. Hickson (Cle - PF,C)
15. (116) James Harden (OKC - SG)

 

Should I trade DRose forTyreke Evans? Last year Evans put up better numbers, but I'm not so sure if he's gonna put up the same numbers. I feel Rose is going to have a stronger year since he has a stronger team. Especially when Boozer comes back. What do you guys think?

 

Should I start Toney Douglas or JR Smith this week?

 

I think you'll get better stats with Evans. DRose is good but there's a reason why Evans is rated higher. Evans came up very big for me last year. Not many people average at least 20/5/5... Rose doesn't...

 

Evans will put up the same numbers, if not better. I am on the Tyreke bandwagon.

 

It all depends on how many minutes they'll get and how many games they play this week.

 

It's a good bandwagon to be on...

 

Nah, I'd keep either of them over Wall. Yeah, Wall will get you assists and steals, but he'll kill your FG%.

I would certainly do Griffin for Rondo though. Immediately. Rondo also rebounds.

 

18 team h2h league, normal categories.

Should I trade Jeff Teague and DeJuan (DeOnly) Blair for Yao Ming and Matt Bonner?

 

I say yes, yes and yes. Yao will give you just as many minutes, probably more points and ft's as blair and bonner-teague is a wash.

 

Why ask? I already accepted. :grin:

Being off my team is the best thing for Yao's career. Trust me.